Spot vs Perpetual Strategy Costs: A Worked Comparison
Compare equal notional exposure before comparing leverage, fees or a headline return.
Start With One Economic Question
Would the same directional idea survive the costs of two different instruments? That is a narrower question than which market is best. Fix the exposure, holding window and entry and exit assumptions before calculating either route. A cash-funded spot purchase and a margined perpetual are not equivalent contracts, even when both respond to the same asset price. A borrowed spot position adds borrowing costs that the cash-funded example below deliberately excludes.
For this teaching example, use $10,000 of initial notional and an assumed 1% favourable move. The gross price gain is $100 under a simplified constant-notional approximation. These are invented inputs, not current prices, exchange quotes or a tested strategy. The calculation answers a cost question only; it does not assign any likelihood to the move.
Build the Spot Cost Line
Assume spot execution fees of 10 basis points on entry and 10 on exit, plus 5 basis points of adverse slippage on each side. The simplified round-trip cost is 30 basis points, or $30 on $10,000. The net scenario gain is therefore $70. With no price move, the same scenario loses $30. One basis point is 0.01%, so multiplying notional by basis points and dividing by 10,000 converts the assumption to dollars.
Actual exit notional changes as price changes. Fees may be charged in a different asset, and maker status is not guaranteed merely because a limit order was entered. Record the actual fee currency and conversions when reconciling a real account. Do not combine a favourable mid-price entry with a conservative exit and call the result a measured fill.
Add Funding Without Annualising Away the Risk
For the perpetual route, assume fees of 4 basis points per side and slippage of 3 per side: 14 basis points, or $14, before funding. Then assume the position pays 2 basis points at each of six funding events. The flat-rate, fixed-notional approximation adds $12 and leaves a $74 net gain from the assumed $100 move. If the rate is instead 8 basis points at each event, funding is $48 and the net gain falls to $38.
These rates and six events are scenario inputs, not any venue's schedule. Funding can be a debit or credit, rates can change, and the amount may use event-specific marked notional. The worksheet uses a signed cost: positive means paid, negative means received. A funding credit is not guaranteed yield. Coinbase's cited documentation illustrates one product's mechanism, not a universal settlement clock.
Separate Exposure From Collateral
Posting $2,000 instead of $10,000 of collateral does not make the $10,000 exposure smaller. In the simplified example, the $100 gross move is unchanged. Dividing the gain by posted collateral produces a different percentage, but leaves out liquidation, collateral price changes and variation in margin requirements. Comparing that percentage with a cash-funded spot return can disguise the change in denominator.
A stop instruction and a liquidation threshold are also different. Do not use this cost worksheet as a liquidation calculator. Confirm the exact contract multiplier, collateral asset, margin mode, mark-price rules and regional eligibility directly with the venue. A strategy that depends on remaining open through a funding event needs those mechanics in its execution specification.
Use a Sensitivity Decision, Not a Winner Badge
Calculate at least a flat-price case, the intended favourable move and an adverse move with wider slippage. Change one cost input at a time so the source of deterioration is visible. If the idea only works with funding credits or perfect maker fills, that dependency belongs in the conclusion. If a venue or contract is unavailable to you, remove that route rather than substituting a similar-looking symbol.
Save the entered assumptions alongside the worksheet export. A useful conclusion might be that the expected price move is too small relative to plausible friction, or that the holding window crosses an uncertain funding event. Neither conclusion proves a profitable alternative. The chart on this site is a deterministic cost sensitivity illustration, not a return history.
Primary Sources
- Kraken: spot and futures mechanics
- Coinbase: funding settlement mechanics
- Coinbase: funding rate mechanism
- QuantConnect: slippage modelling
Crypto Friction Budget Worksheet
Continue the Research
Compare approximations with their assumptions matched
The original fixed-notional model is useful because its costs are explicit, but exit fee notional does not change with the path. With entry/exit fees four and six basis points, zero slippage and six two-basis-point funding debits, its 10,000-notional one-percent gain leaves 78. The new linear case uses 100 reference units, entry 100 and exit 101, so the exit fee is 6.06 and net is 77.94 after the same 12 funding debit. The six-hundredths difference is an authored fee-base distinction. The original default of 74 has different fee/slippage inputs and is not the matched comparator.